A month back families of 200 people murdered in the Troubles accused David Cameron’s government of censoring files that could explain more the circumstances of their deaths (see copy of advertisement, below, published in The Guardian). The British Government has so far refused to release, unredacted, these files on grounds of ‘national security’. But peace in Northern Ireland can never be realised as long as Government cover-ups continue or vital evidence concealed. It has long been known that one British military intelligence section, the Force Research Unit, colluded with the Protestant paramilitaries and infiltrated Republican paramilitaries: its mission, to disseminate disinformation, direct paramilitary operations and – ultimately – eliminate Republican activists as part of a ‘strategy of tension’. A ‘Restricted’ document that provides the unexpurgated testimony of a FRU operative is published below and, when examined in relation to other key documents, provides further evidence of what some have referred to as Britain’s own ‘Killing Fields’.
Note: this article forms part of a summary article in The Canary.
A. The testimony
Here is the statement marked ‘Restricted’ by Martin Ingram (real name Ian Hurst). This is complemented by another statement by Hurst to the Smithwick Tribunal of Inquiry (Dublin). Also referenced below is the 2012 Pat Finucane Review.
“That 98.5% of those arrested were on the British secret state payroll is the most surprising thing I have read for a very long time. These were on the Loyalist side of the conflict – allies. Essentially, of the British state – and I think we may assume that on the Republican side a lower percentage of the combatants had been recruited by the British sate.” (Source: Spy versus Spy – section re Smithwick Tribunal.)
When the contents of the ‘Restricted’ testimony by Ingram/Hurst are examined in relation to the contents of the other two documents, what is revealed is:
1. The allegation – according to Hurst – that Sinn Fein leader Martin McGuinness fired the first shot at Bloody Sunday was false.
2. The Force Research Unit (FRU) allegedly had a file on suspected rogue gardai who were prepared to pass information to the IRA and act as FRU agents. MI5 also allegedly had a network of agents within the Garda.
3. One in four IRA members was allegedly a British agent.
4. At the centre of this web of intrigue sat the IRA’s head of internal security, the agent known as ‘Stakeknife’, who allegedly took information from rogue gardai while he worked for British intelligence. ‘Stakeknife’ has widely been identified as Freddie Scappaticci, a veteran Belfast republican. It should be emphasised, however, that Scappaticci has strongly denied working for British intelligence and claims he cut his links with the IRA in 1990.
B. The Hurst/Ingram ‘restricted’ testimony unpicked
Bloody Sunday took place on 30 January 1972 in the Bogside area of Derry, Northern Ireland. British soldiers shot 26 unarmed civilians during a protest march against internment. Fourteen people died: thirteen were killed outright, while the death of another man four months later was attributed to his injuries. Many of the victims were shot while fleeing from the soldiers and some were shot while trying to help the wounded. Other protesters were injured by rubber bullets or batons, and two were run down by army vehicles.
Two investigations have been held by the British government. The Widgery Tribunal, held in the immediate aftermath of the incident, largely cleared the soldiers and British authorities of blame. Many considered it to be a whitewash. The Saville Inquiry was established in 1998 to re-investigate the incident. 12 years later the Saville report was made public and concluded that the killings were both “unjustified” and “unjustifiable”. But not all testimony was published.
Saville found that all of those shot were unarmed, that none were posing a serious threat, that no bombs were thrown, and that soldiers “knowingly put forward false accounts” to justify their firing. David Cameron then made a formal apology on behalf of the United Kingdom to the victims.
At the subsequent Bloody Sunday Inquiry, Ian Hurst (aka Martin Ingram) was served with an injunction, preventing him from revealing sensitive intelligence, to which he had been asked to give evidence. However, this injunction was varied to allow him to speak in closed session.
It is this closed session evidence, marked ‘Restricted’, that is revealed and referred to (in summary) here:
- Pages 11-14: separate restricted memo refuting earlier allegation that Martin McGuinness fired first shot at Bloody Sunday.
- Page 27, section 26: “The FRU was disbanded in name only – primarily because of the bad press that was received via Brian Nelson but the following day was reformed under a different name but exactly the same structure and take it from me the unit that is in operation within Ebrington Barracks with responsibility for agent handling still has custody of those documents and they are absolutely priceless for any incoming handler to read to gain some idea and some degree of the history and the magnitude of Derry as a city and to gain some tangible way of actually gaining experience of how the city of Derry and the people within need handling and its absolutely invaluable and many of those casual contacts get revisited over a number of years. Obviously some of them are dead you know through old age hopefully and one or two of them are dead you know through problems that have been associated through handling. However lets not dwell on that but however let me just say one thing that that information is still available and still within the Army’s control.”
- Page 43, section 7: Ingram (Hurst) confirms a second time that there was no information that Martin McGuinness fired the first shot on Bloody Sunday.
C. Role of the FRU in the ‘Killing Fields’
Hurst/Ingram was an agent of the FRU, which was a para-judicial death squad, its modus operandi little different from that employed by paramilitaries. Many FRU members not only infiltrated the IRA, the PIRA and the UDA (its overall objective was to neutralize as many paramilitary members as possible) but were complicit in the actions of these paramilitary forces.
The FRU was headed by Colonel Gordon Kerr, a counter-insurgency expert from the SAS. According to a FRU source (Hurst?) who was interviewed by Neil Mackay of The Sunday Herald, “There was an unbroken chain of command running from the handlers, to Kerr, then through to the military top brass in Ulster, on to the Ministry of Defence Chiefs of Staff, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland and finally the Prime Minister. At the time of Finucane’s death George Younger was Secretary of State for Defence, Tom King was Ulster Secretary, Thatcher was Prime Minister and General Sir John Waters was the general officer commanding in Northern Ireland”. The source added: “‘I can say with dead certainty that the FRU did conspire to murder certain individuals with loyalist terrorists through our work withUDA informers. And Kerr knew about it”.
Altogether, it has been estimated that 15 innocent civilians died as a direct result of FRU/UDA collusion with paramilitary forces. During the conflict, loyalist paramilitaries killed 864 civilians, the vast majority of them were Catholics.
The following points relating to FRU operations are extracted from the Pat Finucane Rreview:
- On the lax or negligble handling of FRU agents – see sections 4.82 and 4.86 of PFR
- How FRU agent(s) received orders via PIRA – see section 4.83 of PFR
- How Brian Nelson was recruited by FRU… In 1992 Nelson pleaded guilty to five cases of conspiracy to murder (and 10 cases of attempted murder). Between 1984 and 1985 he played a key role in the attempted murder of a Sinn Fein councillor. In 1987 he became an Intelligence Officer for the UDA (Ulster Defence Association) though was actually working for FRU – see pages 7 – 9 of PFR.
- A definition of FRU (Force Research Unit): operated from 1982 to 1990s (then renamed Joint Services Group) – see section 3.16 of PFR)
- Brian Nelson was run by Colonel Gordon Kerr (FRU) and Captain Margaret ‘M’ Walshaw (FRU). Kerr was a counter-insurgency expert from SAS.
- It is estimated that 15 innocent civilians died as a result of FRU/UDA collusion. Around “98% of Loyalist paramilitaries were British Intelligence operatives” (Spy versus Spy).
- Brian Nelson, Ken Barrett and William Stobie were accused of the murder of lawyer Pat Finucane, who was shot 14 times in front of his family. Nelson, who was Chief of Intelligence for the UDA, was believed to have been responsible (directly or indirectly) for the murder of Finucane. (See pages 132 – 153 for details & summary on page 399 of PFR)
- Nelson was found guilty of Finucane’s murder, but given early release. He was assassinated on 3 February 1992: no one has been arrested/charged for his murder. William Stobie (an RUC agent and a UDA quartermaster) was tried for his role in the murder of Finucane. Stobie is now dead. A BBC Panorama special claimed that UDA activist Ken Barrett drove the car to Finucane’s home, where he was murdered. Barrett was found guilty of complicity in the murder, but after three years was relocated.
Further details re FRU activities can be found in the Smithwick Tribunal Inquiry:
Explanatory intro… The Smithwick Tribunal was set up to investigate the murder of RUC Chief Superintendent Harry Breen and Superintendent Robert Buchanan on 20 March 1989. The suspected killer was a member of the RUC (Royal Ulster Constabulary) who was working with the Gardai (Republic of Ireland police). Chief Superintendent Harry Breen and Supt Robert Buchanan were shot dead while returning from a meeting at Dundalk Garda station in the Republic. The Smithwick Tribunal heard evidence from a number of witnesses, some of whom alleged that members of the Garda passed information to the IRA. One of the alleged rogue officers in Dundalk had already been identified: Owen Corrigan, a detective sergeant, was named by Jeffrey Donaldson under Parliamentary privilege. Mr Corrigan, now retired, has always denied the allegations and appeared at the Smithwick Tribunal to reject them.
But the Tribunal uncovered a whole lot more…
- Ian Hurst (aka Martin Ingram) worked for the FRU at its East and North divisions (N. Ireland) and was allegedly recruited by Willie Carlin and Brian Nelson (both former British Army and loyalists who also worked for FRU/MI5). Ingram/Hurst was the alleged handler of Frank Hegarty. Ingram/Hurst allegedly threatened to expose five agents who had infiltrated the IRA. One of these was allegedly John Magee. Ingram reckons that MI5 provided intelligence to the UDA via Nelson. Philip Campbell-Smith (former FRU agent) allegedly threatened Ingram. In his testimony to Smithwick, Ingram/Hurst claimed that ‘Stakeknife’ was aware of the plot to murder RUC Chief Superintendent Harry Breen and Superintendent Bob Buchanan in 1989.
- Ingram/Hurst claimed that one in four IRA members were either informants or working directly for British Intelligence. Further, the Smithwick Inquiry document states that of 210 terrorist suspects arrested, only three were not security force agents and some worked for several agencies.
- Kevin Fulton (aka Peter Keeley) was another British agent who allegedly infiltrated PIRA. Fulton claims he warned the RUC of the 1998 Omagh bombing by the Real IRA and that British Intelligence were aware the bombing was planned.
- According to one newspaper, Stakeknife’s identity was actually exposed by a loyalist terrorist, who had been given a false identity and who resented the more generous resettlement terms offered to Stakeknife. Another paper claimed he was named by former FRU agents after the MoD failed to provide them with resettlement packages. Fulton, who had previously threatened to expose Stakeknife because the Ministry of Defence were refusing him a resettlement package, categorically denied that he had named him. Fulton claims he went AWOL because Scappaticci wanted him dead. Stakeknife’s existence first came into the public domain when Martin Ingram talked about him to The Sunday Times. He too has denied naming Scappaticci.
D. Other relevant information:
- From 1982-1990, Martin Ingram was in Londonderry, allegedly handling agents like Frank Hegarty, an IRA quartermaster who was later allegedly murdered for betraying a cache of Libyan weapons.
- Fulton claimed he had flown to New York, met FBI and MI5 agents and was given money to buy an infra-red device to be used to set off IRA bombs.
- Fulton reportedly said that: “the real reason why the Real IRA murderers who planted the bomb at Omagh have never been taken to court or their cases investigated is because the actual bomber, Sean Hoey, was also working for the RUC (the police)”.
The ‘Restricted’ document, examined in relation to other published sources, provides a glimpse into the working of the Force Research Unit. But the families of those killed directly by the FRU or via its intervention will require far more information on the role of the FRU if there is to be any justice at all.
- Special Branch men ‘allowed Belfast lawyer to be murdered’: http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2002/oct/20/northernireland
- Revealed: five British spies inside IRA: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2003/may/18/uk.northernireland1
- Deadly army plot to frame UDA man: http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2000/jun/11/northernireland.henrymcdonald
- Scandal of the secret killers: http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2002/jun/23/henrymcdonald.focus
- British spy ‘gagged’ over Omagh: http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2006/nov/12/northernireland.henrymcdonald
- Smithwick tribunal told spymasters could have averted double murder: http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/sep/11/ira-murders-claim-to-smithwick
- Faint echoes of Ulster’s ‘dirty war’: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/blog/2011/jan/11/faint-echoes-of-ulsters-dirty-war
- An overlooked Panorama scoop as a British soldier breaks cover: http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/greenslade/2011/mar/16/bbc-ireland?CMP=twt_f
- Minister gagged media to guard dirty secret: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2003/may/13/northernireland.northernireland1
- Part transcript from Bloody Sunday inquiry: >http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20101103103930/http://report.bloody-sunday-inquiry.org/transcripts/Archive/Ts329.htm
- Finucane facts we need to know: http://slugghttp://www.patfinucanecentre.org/fru/fru12022k1a.htmlerotoole.com/2012/12/12/finucane-facts-we-need-to-know<
- Finucane controversy won’t lie down: http://sluggerotoole.com/2012/12/13/finucane-controversy-wont-die-down/
- Rogue British agents name MI5 bosses in video expose: http://www.prisonplanet.com/news_alert_mi5terror_7.html
- Half of all top IRA men ‘worked for security services’: http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/half-of-all-top-ira-men-worked-for-security-services-28694353.html
- Is Martin McGuinness a British Agent? https://wikispooks.com/wiki/Document:Is_Martin_McGuinness_a_British_Agent%3F
- Article by Martin Ingram (Ian Hurst): https://cryptome.org/ingram-spies.htm
- More on the McGuiness Story (by Slugger O’Toole): http://sluggerotoole.com/2006/06/02/more_on_the_mcguinness_theory/
- Beyond Collusion: The UK Security Forces and the murder of Pat Finucane: https://www.humanrightsfirst.org/wp-content/uploads/pdf/beyond_collusion.pdf